Homemade vs Store-Bought Dog Treats
How small-batch, all-natural baking compares to mass-produced treats on the shelf.
Two very different things in the same aisle
Mass-produced treats are built to sit on a shelf for a year or more, which usually means preservatives, fillers, and ingredients chosen for cost and shelf life. Small-batch, freshly baked treats are built to be eaten soon, which means they can be made from real food and nothing else.
How they compare
- Ingredients. Homemade-style can stick to recognizable whole foods; mass-produced often leans on fillers and chemical preservatives.
- Freshness. Small batches are baked close to when you get them.
- Transparency. A small maker can tell you exactly what is in every treat and where it was made.
Tater Bear Treats are hand-baked in small batches in New Jersey with real people-food ingredients, no preservatives, salt, or sugar, and full nutritional information from independent laboratory testing on every recipe.
Store-bought convenience has its place, but if you want to know exactly what your dog is eating, fresh and small-batch is hard to beat.
Shop our treatsExplore more
Frequently asked questions
Are small-batch treats really better than store-bought?
They can be made from real food with no preservatives because they are baked fresh, not built for a year on a shelf. You also get full transparency on ingredients.
Do you ship nationwide?
Yes, we ship across the United States, with free shipping on orders over $45.